Carney Tells Quebec Premier He Cannot Negotiate Separate U.S. Trade Deals as Trump Talks Continue

35,000+ smart investors are already getting financial news, market signals, and macro shifts in the economy that could impact their money next with our FREE weekly newsletter. Get ahead of what the crowd finds out too late. Click Here to Subscribe for FREE.

A friendly first meeting between Prime Minister Mark Carney and Quebec Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon has exposed a sharp disagreement over who gets to speak for Canada in Washington. On November 16, Carney ruled out Quebec negotiating its own trade deal with the United States, even as the province presses to play a larger role in confronting President Donald Trump’s tariffs. The warning came a day after the two leaders met at the Francophonie summit in Cambodia, where they found common ground on domestic concerns. With Canada-U.S. trade talks still unresolved, Ottawa is drawing a distinction between provinces advocating for their economic interests and one federal government conducting negotiations on behalf of the country.

A Friendly First Meeting, Followed by a Firm Warning

At their first one-on-one meeting in Phnom Penh on November 15, Carney and St-Pierre Plamondon struck an unexpectedly warm tone. They joked about their shared experience playing hockey at Oxford University, discussed challenges such as homelessness and affordability, and exchanged personal telephone numbers. The Quebec premier described their conversation as enjoyable and constructive. After weeks of friction over when and where they would meet, the encounter suggested that a working relationship might finally be taking shape.

The next day, Carney made clear that goodwill would not translate into separate trade-negotiating powers. Speaking to reporters in Cambodia, he insisted that the federal government would remain Canada’s negotiator with Washington. He also rejected the idea that Quebec could obtain additional independent seats in major international organizations, while promising to share information with the province. Asked about the possibility of a political “bromance,” Carney instead emphasized a friendly but professional relationship. The contrast captured the central tension: two governments willing to cooperate on some priorities, but unwilling to agree on who should lead the country’s dealings with the United States.

Quebec’s Own Outreach Has Already Raised Tensions

The dispute did not begin in Cambodia. Following the November 3 U.S. midterm elections, St-Pierre Plamondon’s government launched an effort to build relationships with newly elected American officials. The premier sent letters to roughly 60 politicians in states that trade with Quebec, hoping to find allies prepared to push back against tariffs. On November 10, he also met Bloc Québécois Leader Yves-François Blanchet to discuss a coordinated strategy for easing trade tensions.

For the Quebec government, contacting governors and lawmakers is a way of defending companies that sell into the American market. Such outreach can help explain how a tariff affects a particular mill, manufacturer or employer, even if the person receiving the letter cannot unilaterally lift federal tariffs. Carney, however, questioned the wisdom of having more than one negotiator. St-Pierre Plamondon answered with a hockey metaphor, suggesting Ottawa wanted the entire rink to itself. Their disagreement is therefore not simply about whether Quebec can talk to Americans; it is about how far those conversations should go while Ottawa pursues a national agreement.

The Constitutional Line Between Diplomacy and a Trade Deal

Canada’s constitutional structure gives Ottawa the leading role in negotiating international trade agreements. Section 91 of the Constitution Act, 1867 assigns the regulation of trade and commerce to Parliament, while treaty negotiation and ratification are conducted by the federal executive. A province cannot independently negotiate a Canadian tariff schedule or replace the federal government as Washington’s counterpart in a national trade pact. That is the practical boundary behind Carney’s position.

There is, however, more room for provincial international activity than a simple ban on foreign contacts would suggest. Quebec and U.S. states have long cooperated on matters within their own responsibilities, including environmental policy and investment promotion. Provinces also help implement international commitments touching provincial jurisdiction, which makes their participation in federal negotiations important. The distinction is between promoting trade or arranging cooperation and concluding an international free-trade treaty. Quebec can make its economic case directly to influential Americans, but changing the trade rules governing goods crossing the Canada-U.S. border requires action through the appropriate federal authorities.

Why Trump Remains the Central Figure in the Talks

The political landscape in Washington has changed, but Carney argues that the negotiating channel has not. Democrats won control of both houses of Congress in the November midterms and have pledged to challenge tariffs that they say raise costs for American households. Quebec’s premier sees an opportunity to build alliances with those lawmakers. From that perspective, outreach beyond the White House could increase pressure for a change in U.S. trade policy.

Carney’s calculation is more immediate. On November 10, he said the executive branch, led by President Trump, would remain the decisive counterpart for trade negotiations over the coming years. Members of Congress can hold hearings, introduce bills and contest tariffs, but legislation may still encounter a presidential veto. That does not make Quebec’s contacts irrelevant; it means there is a difference between winning sympathetic voices and securing enforceable tariff relief. For Ottawa, maintaining one negotiating position is a way to avoid contradictory promises or expectations as discussions with Trump’s administration continue.

August’s Breakdown Still Shapes Every Conversation

Canada’s current trade diplomacy carries the memory of a serious setback. In August, Ottawa suspended negotiations after the American side advanced terms that Carney said threatened Canada’s economic interests and sovereignty. His government singled out demands affecting the French language, cultural protections and the independence of Canadian decision-making. The dispute unfolded alongside new U.S. tariffs, including a 50% rate applied to specified categories of Canadian products rather than to every export crossing the border.

Ottawa responded with retaliatory measures, and the interruption left businesses facing uncertainty about how long the confrontation would last. By November, talks had resumed, but their outcome remained unsettled. On November 14, Carney said he had held a substantial conversation with Trump and senior U.S. officials and that the two sides were making progress. He did not announce an agreement, and he stressed that Canada would not accept terms that undermined its automotive industry. That unresolved history explains why both the federal government and Quebec are eager to influence the direction of the negotiations.

Quebec’s Export Numbers Explain the Urgency

The province has substantial economic reasons to worry about access to the American market. According to the Institut de la statistique du Québec, Quebec exported about $40.5 billion in merchandise to the United States during the first six months of 2026. That represented 68.2% of the province’s international merchandise exports. Shipments to the U.S. were down 7.2%, or roughly $3.2 billion, from the same period in 2025. Those figures establish the scale of Quebec’s exposure, although they do not prove that tariffs caused the entire decline.

The industries involved are also more varied than the familiar image of cross-border trucking suggests. Among Quebec’s major export categories are aluminum, aircraft, aircraft engines and aerospace components. A change in American duties or purchasing decisions can ripple from a large factory into smaller suppliers, shipping companies and communities dependent on those paycheques. For a provincial premier, making that local impact visible in U.S. political circles is an understandable priority. For Ottawa, the challenge is turning regional concerns into a negotiating package that can protect Canadian industries across the country.

A Sovereigntist Premier Wants More International Space

St-Pierre Plamondon leads a Parti Québécois government that favours Quebec independence, so the argument about trade representation has a broader political meaning. His administration wants the province to be seen internationally as more than one stakeholder among many. Carney’s response on November 16 was to defend a national approach while pointing out that Quebec already has an established voice in the French-speaking world.

That voice is significant. Quebec and New Brunswick are full members of the Organisation internationale de la Francophonie alongside Canada, and Quebec has had official representation within Canada’s delegation to UNESCO since 2006. During the Cambodia summit, Ottawa also confirmed that Canada will host the 2028 Francophonie summit in the National Capital Region. Those arrangements offer opportunities for cultural diplomacy and economic networking, but they do not confer authority to negotiate a separate U.S. tariff deal. The disagreement reveals a familiar Canadian federalism question in a new setting: how to recognize Quebec’s distinct identity while keeping the country’s treaty negotiations coherent.

Homelessness and a 2027 Summit Offer Common Ground

Trade was not the only subject at the leaders’ Cambodia meeting. St-Pierre Plamondon said they made progress on Quebec’s response to homelessness, with Carney agreeing to let the province choose projects supported through federal funding and coordinate the spending with its own priorities. That is the premier’s account of the understanding; detailed bilateral funding terms had not been announced. The issue matters because cities and community organizations need both resources and clear decisions about which government directs them.

There was also agreement in principle on an international economic gathering. Carney supported Quebec’s plan to bring Francophone economic ministers and businesses to Quebec City in 2027, giving the province a platform to develop commercial relationships outside the United States. The leaders have discussed meeting again in Quebec City, potentially in December. These initiatives show that disputes over foreign trade authority do not prevent practical cooperation. In fact, finding room to work together on housing and investment could help keep communication open when negotiations over tariffs or international representation become more difficult.

The CUSMA Review Makes a Unified Approach More Consequential

Beyond the latest bilateral discussions lies the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement, or CUSMA, which entered into force on July 1, 2020. Its first mandatory six-year joint review fell in 2026. The review is not an automatic expiry of the pact; the framework provides for a term extending to 2036 unless the parties change its course. It offers the three governments a chance to assess whether trade rules still serve an increasingly strained North American economy.

That distinction matters because a possible Canada-U.S. tariff understanding and the trilateral CUSMA framework are connected but not identical. Automobiles, aerospace parts, steel and aluminum move through integrated supply chains, often crossing borders more than once before reaching buyers. Changes to tariffs, rules of origin or market-access conditions could affect Quebec producers and companies elsewhere in Canada simultaneously. A national negotiating team must therefore balance demands that do not always align neatly between provinces or industries. Quebec has a strong reason to seek influence, but a province-by-province trade bargain would not provide a workable replacement for continent-wide rules.

What Happens Next Depends on Coordination, Not Separate Deals

Carney has offered information-sharing with Quebec, and Canada’s trade-policy process already provides avenues for provincial input. Global Affairs Canada describes regular federal-provincial-territorial consultations on negotiating priorities, including sectors that fall partly within provincial jurisdiction. Those arrangements are less visible than a premier writing directly to U.S. politicians, but they give Quebec opportunities to present industry-specific concerns before federal officials settle their positions.

For now, the test is whether both governments can use those channels without turning every contact with Washington into another jurisdictional dispute. Quebec can keep explaining the impact of tariffs to American states and businesses. Ottawa can keep negotiating with Trump’s administration while drawing on that intelligence. Neither approach guarantees relief, and as of November 16 there was no newly concluded Canada-U.S. trade deal to announce. The stakes are concrete: exporters need predictable access to customers, workers need confidence in future orders, and Canadians need to know who is speaking for them when the terms of North American commerce are being decided.

This Options Discord Chat is The Real Deal

While the internet is scoured with trading chat rooms, many of which even charge upwards of thousands of dollars to join, this smaller options trading discord chatroom is the real deal and actually providing valuable trade setups, education, and community without the noise and spam of the larger more expensive rooms. With a incredibly low-cost monthly fee, Options Trading Club (click here to see their reviews) requires an application to join ensuring that every member is dedicated and serious about taking their trading to the next level. If you are looking for a change in your trading strategies, then click here to apply for a membership.

Join the #1 Exclusive Community for Stock Investors

35,000+ smart investors are already getting financial news, market signals, and macro shifts in the economy that could impact their money next with our FREE weekly newsletter. Get ahead of what the crowd finds out too late. Click Here to Subscribe for FREE.

This Options Discord Chat is The Real Deal

While the internet is scoured with trading chat rooms, many of which even charge upwards of thousands of dollars to join, this smaller options trading discord chatroom is the real deal and actually providing valuable trade setups, education, and community without the noise and spam of the larger more expensive rooms. With a incredibly low-cost monthly fee, Options Trading Club (click here to see their reviews) requires an application to join ensuring that every member is dedicated and serious about taking their trading to the next level. If you are looking for a change in your trading strategies, then click here to apply for a membership.

Revir Media Group
447 Broadway
2nd FL #750
New York, NY 10013