Former Trump-Era Trade Officials and Pence-Linked Group Join Legal Fight Against Trump’s 50% Tariffs on Canada

35,000+ smart investors are already getting financial news, market signals, and macro shifts in the economy that could impact their money next with our FREE weekly newsletter. Get ahead of what the crowd finds out too late. Click Here to Subscribe for FREE.

President Donald Trump’s escalating trade war with Canada is facing a new challenge from an unexpected group of American conservatives, former senior trade officials and legal experts.

On November 16, the Liberty Justice Center announced that former U.S. Trade Representatives Carla Hills and Robert Zoellick, alongside an organization founded by former Vice President Mike Pence, had submitted legal briefs supporting a lawsuit against Trump’s 50% tariffs on selected Canadian goods.

The dispute centres on whether the president exceeded his authority by invoking a rarely used law dating back to 1930. The case also exposes the unexpected costs of the trade conflict for American businesses, including a food importer paying additional tariffs on Canadian cheese produced using milk from American farms.

With a federal court hearing scheduled for January 2027, the challenge could have consequences extending well beyond the current Canada-U.S. trade dispute.

Former U.S. Trade Officials Are Challenging Trump’s Tariff Authority

The latest development brings several influential figures from America’s trade-policy establishment into an increasingly consequential legal battle. On November 16, the Liberty Justice Center confirmed that former U.S. Trade Representatives Carla Hills and Robert Zoellick had joined other experts in supporting a challenge to the Trump administration’s use of Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930. Their involvement comes through amicus briefs, legal submissions that allow outside parties to provide arguments or expertise in an existing court case. They are supporting the plaintiff rather than launching separate lawsuits.

The case, Gellert Global Group Corp. v. Trump, was originally filed on October 20 in the U.S. Court of International Trade. It argues that the administration exceeded the authority Congress granted when it imposed additional 50% tariffs on selected Canadian imports. The participation of experienced trade officials adds credibility to the legal challenge, although it does not determine how judges will rule. These figures served across several previous administrations, rather than all being former Trump appointees. Their opposition is particularly notable because it comes from individuals familiar with how American presidents negotiate trade agreements and enforce restrictions.

Carla Hills Helped Negotiate NAFTA and Now Questions Trump’s Approach

Carla Hills brings an unusually relevant perspective to the dispute. She served as United States Trade Representative under President George H.W. Bush from 1989 to 1993 and played a central role in negotiating the original North American Free Trade Agreement. That agreement helped establish the framework for economic integration between Canada, the United States and Mexico. Hills also oversaw investigations into unfair foreign trade practices, including disputes involving Canada’s provincial beer regulations. Her experience gives her direct knowledge of the legal mechanisms Washington has historically used when confronting trading partners.

Hills joined former trade officials Alan Wolff and Warren Maruyama in arguing that Congress effectively replaced the older tariff provisions with a more comprehensive enforcement system established in 1974. Wolff helped draft the legislation that became Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 and later served as a senior World Trade Organization official from 2017 to 2021. Maruyama served as general counsel of the U.S. Trade Representative’s office under President George W. Bush. Separately, Robert Zoellick, who served as trade representative under George W. Bush, joined former State Department official Philip Zelikow in questioning whether the 1930 law can properly be applied to Canada.

Mike Pence’s Conservative Organization Has Joined the Legal Challenge

Perhaps the most politically revealing development is the involvement of Advancing American Freedom, the conservative advocacy organization founded by former Vice President Mike Pence. Pence served alongside Trump during his first presidential administration and launched the organization in April 2021 to promote conservative policies, including limited government and constitutional principles. Its participation demonstrates that criticism of the administration’s tariff strategy is not confined to Democrats, Canadian officials or businesses traditionally opposed to protectionist trade policies.

Advancing American Freedom joined the National Taxpayers Union Foundation, Competitive Enterprise Institute, Tax Foundation and other supporters in questioning the statutory and constitutional foundation of the Canadian tariffs. Their brief argues that Congress holds the constitutional authority to impose tariffs and that presidential powers must remain within the limits established by legislation. The group’s position does not necessarily imply opposition to every form of trade protection. Instead, its argument focuses on the possibility that the administration has interpreted a nearly century-old statute too broadly. The distinction matters politically because it introduces a conservative constitutional argument against one of Trump’s most prominent economic policies, potentially complicating efforts to portray the legal challenge as simply partisan opposition.

American Milk Is Being Taxed When It Returns as Canadian Cheese

One of the most revealing examples in the lawsuit involves a product that begins its journey in the United States. According to the Liberty Justice Center, one of Gellert Global Group’s Canadian suppliers purchases milk from dairy farmers in upstate New York. The milk is transported to Canada, where it is processed into brie cheese before being shipped back to American customers. Under Trump’s Section 338 tariffs, the finished cheese faces an additional 50% import duty when it re-enters the United States, despite being made from milk originally supplied by American farmers.

The situation illustrates how deeply connected North American supply chains have become. Gellert is a third-generation, family-owned food importer headquartered in New Jersey, with operations involving imported foods and American agricultural producers. In its original court complaint, the company reported paying more than US$381,000 in Section 338 tariffs on certain affected entries between September 15 and early October. The company argues that these charges were collected unlawfully. For an American food distributor, the financial consequences extend beyond the original supplier, potentially affecting pricing decisions, relationships with retailers and the competitiveness of products sold to American consumers.

Trump’s 50% Tariffs Rely on a Law From the Great Depression

At the centre of the dispute is Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, commonly associated with the Smoot-Hawley tariff legislation. The provision allows a president to impose additional duties of up to 50% when a foreign country is found to discriminate against American commerce in specific ways. It also contains provisions permitting import restrictions under certain conditions. Although the law remained on the books for decades, the Congressional Research Service confirms that Trump’s 2026 actions marked the first time a president expressly invoked Section 338 to impose tariffs.

The administration announced the measures on July 20, initially scheduling their implementation for August 19. Following a brief postponement during negotiations, the tariffs took effect on August 22. They targeted selected Canadian products rather than every Canadian export, covering approximately US$20 billion in annual trade based on 2025 import values. The administration has subsequently adjusted the affected product lists and imposed import bans on certain goods. The law’s unusual history has become central to the legal dispute. Opponents argue that its lack of previous use, combined with subsequent changes to American trade legislation, raises serious questions about whether Congress intended it to support such extensive presidential action.

Legal Experts Say Congress Established Stronger Trade Rules in 1974

The central argument advanced by Hills, Wolff and Maruyama concerns the relationship between two American trade laws separated by 44 years. Section 338 was enacted in 1930, when international trade agreements and enforcement procedures were considerably different. Congress subsequently passed Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, which established a more structured framework for responding to unfair foreign trade practices. That framework includes investigations, consultations and other procedural safeguards intended to evaluate alleged discrimination before trade restrictions are imposed.

The former officials argue that Section 301 effectively superseded Section 338 for the types of disputes now being raised against Canada. Their position is that the president should not be able to revive an older, less restrictive statute to bypass the protections Congress created later. However, the question of whether Section 338 has been legally displaced remains contested and has not been resolved in this case. The administration maintains that the statute provides valid presidential authority to respond to discriminatory treatment of American commerce. The court must determine whether the provisions can coexist and, if so, what limitations apply. Its interpretation could influence how future presidents use older trade laws against other countries.

The White House Says Canada Is Discriminating Against American Products

The Trump administration has defended its tariffs as a response to what it considers unfair Canadian treatment of American automobiles, alcoholic beverages and dairy products. In its July announcement, the White House argued that the measures were necessary to offset disadvantages faced by American businesses and protect domestic workers. The administration specifically identified Canadian trade policies and restrictions affecting access to those markets. From Washington’s perspective, the tariffs represent an enforcement tool intended to encourage Canada to change policies that the president believes disadvantage American exporters.

Canada rejects the administration’s characterization of several of these measures. Ottawa maintains that its dairy tariff-rate quota system complies with the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement, while its restrictions and surtaxes involving certain American products were introduced in response to earlier U.S. trade actions. The legal challenge draws an important distinction between discrimination and retaliation. The plaintiffs argue that responding to another country’s tariffs does not automatically constitute unlawful discrimination under Section 338. International trade lawyer Barry Appleton has also questioned the administration’s reliance on differences between Canada’s dairy commitments under CUSMA and its separate agreement with the European Union. The court will have to consider whether the specific Canadian policies satisfy the statute’s legal requirements.

A Separate Dispute Questions Why Trump Selected the Maximum 50% Rate

Even if the court determines that Section 338 remains legally available, the plaintiffs argue that the administration still had to demonstrate why the maximum tariff rate was justified. The statute permits additional duties up to 50%, but describes them as measures intended to offset the burden or disadvantage caused by discriminatory trade practices. Legal experts Gregory Shaffer, Jennifer Hillman and Peter Harrell argue that this requires a connection between the economic harm identified and the tariff imposed. They contend that the administration has not adequately established that connection through a measured assessment of the claimed discrimination.

Another challenge concerns the timing of tariff collection. Section 338 contains a 30-day waiting period before additional duties become effective. According to Gellert’s complaint, the administration added certain Canadian cheeses and other products to the tariff lists on September 8 but began collecting duties on September 15, just seven days later. The company argues that the waiting period should apply to newly added products, not merely the original tariff announcement. This creates a distinct legal issue from the broader challenge to presidential authority. Even if the court upholds some tariffs, it could still consider whether particular duties were collected prematurely and whether affected importers are entitled to refunds.

Canada’s Retaliation Has Turned the Dispute Into a Wider Economic Conflict

The legal confrontation comes after months of escalating trade tensions between Ottawa and Washington. When the latest U.S. tariffs took effect on August 22, Canada responded by announcing measures designed to match their economic impact. On September 8, Ottawa implemented counter-tariffs of 15%, 25% and 50% on selected American products, covering approximately C$27.6 billion in imports. The targeted sectors included steel, dairy, appliances, agricultural equipment, pulp and paper, and electronics. The Canadian government said its response was necessary to protect domestic industries and counter what it considered unjustified American restrictions.

The resulting trade barriers create complications for companies operating across the border. Businesses sourcing Canadian components may face higher costs when shipping products into the United States, while Canadian companies purchasing targeted American materials can encounter additional expenses. In some industries, those costs may be absorbed through lower profit margins; in others, companies may attempt to pass them along to customers. The dispute is also complicated by the fact that Section 338 tariffs do not automatically exempt products meeting CUSMA rules of origin. Some affected products can face duties under multiple American trade provisions, making import calculations and long-term business planning increasingly difficult.

A January Court Hearing Could Have Consequences Beyond Canada

The immediate legal timetable is becoming clearer. According to the Liberty Justice Center, oral arguments in Gellert Global Group Corp. v. Trump are scheduled for January 20, 2027. The case is before a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of International Trade, which specializes in disputes involving customs duties and international trade laws. Gellert is asking the court to stop the challenged tariffs, order refunds of unlawfully collected duties with applicable interest and certify a nationwide class of affected American importers. A separate proposed subclass would cover importers charged duties before the disputed waiting period expired.

A victory for the plaintiffs could potentially force significant changes to the administration’s Section 338 tariff measures, although the precise consequences would depend on the scope of the ruling and any subsequent appeals. A government victory, meanwhile, could strengthen the president’s ability to rely on the older statute in future trade conflicts. Neither outcome is guaranteed, and a court decision would not necessarily eliminate tariffs imposed under separate legal authorities. Nevertheless, the arrival of former senior trade officials and Pence-linked conservatives has added a significant dimension to the dispute. For Canada, the case represents another potential source of pressure on Washington at a time when political negotiations alone have not restored stable trading conditions.

This Options Discord Chat is The Real Deal

While the internet is scoured with trading chat rooms, many of which even charge upwards of thousands of dollars to join, this smaller options trading discord chatroom is the real deal and actually providing valuable trade setups, education, and community without the noise and spam of the larger more expensive rooms. With a incredibly low-cost monthly fee, Options Trading Club (click here to see their reviews) requires an application to join ensuring that every member is dedicated and serious about taking their trading to the next level. If you are looking for a change in your trading strategies, then click here to apply for a membership.

Join the #1 Exclusive Community for Stock Investors

35,000+ smart investors are already getting financial news, market signals, and macro shifts in the economy that could impact their money next with our FREE weekly newsletter. Get ahead of what the crowd finds out too late. Click Here to Subscribe for FREE.

This Options Discord Chat is The Real Deal

While the internet is scoured with trading chat rooms, many of which even charge upwards of thousands of dollars to join, this smaller options trading discord chatroom is the real deal and actually providing valuable trade setups, education, and community without the noise and spam of the larger more expensive rooms. With a incredibly low-cost monthly fee, Options Trading Club (click here to see their reviews) requires an application to join ensuring that every member is dedicated and serious about taking their trading to the next level. If you are looking for a change in your trading strategies, then click here to apply for a membership.

Revir Media Group
447 Broadway
2nd FL #750
New York, NY 10013