35,000+ smart investors are already getting financial news, market signals, and macro shifts in the economy that could impact their money next with our FREE weekly newsletter. Get ahead of what the crowd finds out too late. Click Here to Subscribe for FREE.
Canada’s economic productivity gap with the United States has widened to 24.8%, raising fresh questions about how the country can compete with its largest trading partner while improving living standards at home.
A new study released November 20 by economic consulting firm Aviseo Conseil argues that Canada’s proposed high-speed rail network could help address the problem, potentially adding $24.5 billion annually to the country’s economy once fully operational.
The research, commissioned by federal Crown corporation Alto, examines how dramatically faster connections between Toronto, Ottawa, Montréal and Québec City could improve business efficiency, expand access to workers and encourage investment.
However, the ambitious economic projections come with substantial financial uncertainty. Independent estimates suggest constructing the railway could cost as much as $113 billion, making the project’s potential benefits and long-term affordability central questions for Canadian taxpayers.
Canada’s Productivity Gap With the United States Has Reached 24.8%
Canada Trails U.S. Productivity by 24.8% as New Study Claims High-Speed Rail Would Add $24.5 Billion Annually
- Canada’s Productivity Gap With the United States Has Reached 24.8%
- New Research Estimates a $24.5 Billion Annual Boost to Canada’s Economy
- The Toronto–Québec City Corridor Already Powers Much of Canada’s Economy
- High-Speed Trains Could Cut Travel Times Between Major Cities Nearly in Half
- Faster Transportation Could Make Canadian Businesses More Competitive
- Millions More Intercity Trips Could Strain Canada’s Existing Infrastructure
- The Railway Could Carry 24 Million Passengers Annually by 2055
- Construction Could Create More Than 50,000 Jobs, Starting With Ottawa–Montréal
- The Project Could Cost Up to $113 Billion, According to Canada’s Budget Watchdog
- Farmers and Economists Are Calling for Closer Scrutiny of the Benefits
Canada’s longstanding productivity problem has become a major concern for economists and policymakers. According to the Aviseo Conseil study released November 20, Canadian productivity was 24.8% below the American level in 2024. The research also places Canada’s productivity 3.5% below the average among Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development countries. Those comparisons are particularly concerning because productivity—the economic output generated for each hour worked—is closely connected to an economy’s ability to support higher wages, stronger public services and rising living standards.
Statistics Canada has documented the longer-term trend. Between 2000 and 2023, Canadian labour productivity increased by an average of approximately 0.8% annually, compared with 1.9% in the United States. The difference is not necessarily explained by Canadians working fewer hours or putting in less effort. Productivity depends on factors such as technology, machinery, business investment, infrastructure and how effectively workers can perform their jobs. The new research argues that improving transportation connections between Canada’s major economic centres could become one part of a broader solution to this persistent disadvantage.
New Research Estimates a $24.5 Billion Annual Boost to Canada’s Economy
The central finding of the Aviseo study is that Alto’s proposed high-speed rail network could eventually increase Canada’s real gross domestic product by approximately $24.5 billion annually. That represents an estimated 1.1% increase in national economic output once the system is fully operational and its longer-term economic effects have developed. The projected increase would not come primarily from train ticket sales or railway construction. Instead, researchers argue that faster transportation could make Canadian businesses more productive by improving access to workers, customers, suppliers and investment opportunities.
The underlying economic modelling provides a more detailed explanation. In its baseline scenario, Aviseo estimated approximately $21 billion in annual GDP gains from improved productivity, another $2.7 billion from increased labour supply and about $800 million from tourism-related activity. The underlying model reports a total of approximately $24.4 billion, while the latest public release uses $24.5 billion. Results vary considerably under different assumptions, with estimated annual GDP effects ranging from $14.8 billion to $41 billion. These are forecasts based on economic modelling, not guaranteed financial returns. The analysis also does not establish whether the projected gains would exceed the full costs of constructing, financing and operating the railway.
The Toronto–Québec City Corridor Already Powers Much of Canada’s Economy
One reason researchers believe high-speed rail could have a substantial economic effect is the concentration of people and businesses along the proposed route. According to Aviseo, the Toronto–Québec City corridor contains approximately 41% of Canada’s population and generates around 40% of national GDP. The region includes major financial institutions, universities, manufacturing operations, technology companies, government offices and research facilities. It also contains some of the country’s most heavily travelled transportation routes, making it a particularly important region for economic activity.
Alto’s planned network would stretch approximately 1,000 kilometres, connecting Toronto, Peterborough, Ottawa, Montréal, Laval, Trois-Rivières and Québec City. A potential additional stop in Kingston is being assessed, although the final route has not been confirmed. The economic argument is that connecting these centres more efficiently could make them function more like a single integrated region rather than separate markets divided by hours of travel. A technology business based in Toronto, for example, could find it easier to collaborate with researchers in Montréal, while companies in smaller communities could gain more convenient access to customers and professional services in larger cities. Whether those opportunities translate into the projected economic gains will depend on station locations, ticket prices and actual passenger demand.
High-Speed Trains Could Cut Travel Times Between Major Cities Nearly in Half
The proposed railway would represent a substantial departure from Canada’s existing intercity passenger rail system. Alto plans to operate electric trains travelling at speeds of up to 300 kilometres per hour on a dedicated network. The company estimates that a trip between Toronto and Montréal could take approximately three hours, while Toronto to Ottawa could take about two hours. Travel between Ottawa and Montréal is projected to require roughly one hour, compared with around 90 minutes between Montréal and Québec City. These are planned journey times rather than confirmed operating schedules.
The potential difference becomes clearer when considering how business travel currently works. Someone travelling between Toronto and Montréal may spend several hours driving or navigating airport security, boarding and transportation into the city. A reliable downtown-to-downtown rail connection could make certain meetings possible without requiring an overnight stay. Alto is also considering service frequencies of approximately every 30 minutes during peak periods on some routes, with 20 to 30 daily departures contemplated between Toronto and Montréal. However, final schedules and fares have not been established. The economic benefits depend on the railway being sufficiently fast, frequent, reliable and affordable to persuade people to change how they travel.
Faster Transportation Could Make Canadian Businesses More Competitive
A major component of the proposed economic benefit comes from what economists describe as agglomeration effects. These occur when businesses, employees and institutions become more productive because they can interact more easily with one another. Physical distance can create costs even in an economy where online meetings and digital communications are common. Travelling to meet a client, recruit a specialized employee or collaborate with a research partner still requires time and resources. Reducing those barriers can make existing economic activity more efficient.
Aviseo’s research draws on international experience with high-speed rail to estimate how improved accessibility could influence productivity. The study reviewed 118 research publications and used economic modelling to examine how businesses might respond to reduced travel times. For example, a consulting firm in Ottawa could potentially serve a broader customer base in Montréal, while an engineering company in Peterborough might find it easier to work with clients in Toronto. These examples illustrate the theory rather than documented future outcomes. Importantly, the study suggests that productivity improvements could extend beyond railway passengers themselves, as stronger business networks influence supply chains, investment decisions and employment opportunities throughout the economy.
Millions More Intercity Trips Could Strain Canada’s Existing Infrastructure
The new research also argues that the economic costs of maintaining Canada’s existing transportation system should not be overlooked. Aviseo estimates that annual intercity trips between the cities served by Alto could increase from approximately 80 million today to 115 million by 2059. That represents growth of roughly 44%, creating additional demand on highways, airports and existing rail infrastructure. Without substantial transportation improvements, more passengers could mean greater congestion, longer journey times and increased pressure on public infrastructure.
The study suggests that maintaining the status quo could eventually require more than $50 billion annually in transportation infrastructure investment in Québec and Ontario by 2050 under its modelling scenario. That figure should not be interpreted as a confirmed annual taxpayer loss or an amount automatically saved by constructing Alto. Instead, it reflects assumptions about future transportation demand and the infrastructure that might be needed to accommodate it. Researchers argue that expanding highways alone may not deliver equivalent benefits because additional road capacity can attract more vehicle traffic. High-speed rail could provide an alternative, but the value of that alternative will depend on how many passengers choose trains over cars, buses and aircraft.
The Railway Could Carry 24 Million Passengers Annually by 2055
Alto’s preliminary passenger forecasts suggest the proposed railway could carry as many as 24 million passengers annually by 2055. For comparison, the company estimates that existing passenger rail services in the corridor handled approximately three million trips in 2024. Achieving the projected increase would require a major change in Canadians’ travel habits, with travellers choosing high-speed trains for journeys that might otherwise involve driving, flying or conventional rail. The scale of that anticipated shift is one of the biggest assumptions underlying the project’s long-term economic case.
The potential effects extend beyond business travel. Improved connections could make it easier for tourists to visit several Canadian cities during one trip, supporting hotels, restaurants, cultural attractions and local businesses. Separate research commissioned by Alto suggests that additional tourism spending could contribute approximately $1 billion annually to Canadian GDP and support 11,500 additional jobs under favourable conditions. These tourism estimates are scenario-based and should not automatically be added to the overall $24.5 billion projection because the analyses use different assumptions and may cover overlapping benefits. Still, the possibility of stronger visitor activity illustrates why project supporters see the railway as more than a transportation investment.
Construction Could Create More Than 50,000 Jobs, Starting With Ottawa–Montréal
Beyond the potential long-term productivity improvements, Alto’s construction program is expected to create substantial employment opportunities. Government projections indicate that building the complete high-speed rail system could support more than 50,000 jobs during construction. The work would require engineers, electricians, construction workers, project managers, transportation specialists and a wide range of suppliers. Large quantities of steel, concrete and other construction materials would also be necessary, potentially creating demand across several Canadian industries.
The project’s first construction segment is planned between Ottawa and Montréal, with work expected to begin in 2029, subject to the necessary project development and approvals. An October 2026 analysis from the Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated that construction of this initial section could increase Canadian real GDP by approximately $1.8 billion in 2029, rising to $2 billion annually by 2033. Employment gains associated with the first segment were estimated at approximately 4,300 jobs initially, increasing to 9,000 by 2033. These are projected economic effects during construction, not permanent operating jobs. They also differ from Aviseo’s longer-term productivity estimates, which concern the completed railway and its potential effects on the broader economy.
The Project Could Cost Up to $113 Billion, According to Canada’s Budget Watchdog
The most significant uncertainty surrounding Alto is its enormous construction cost. The Crown corporation’s preliminary estimate places the project between $60 billion and $90 billion. However, a report released October 1 by the Office of the Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated that building the proposed baseline route could cost between $75 billion and $113 billion, expressed in 2024 dollars. The independent estimate does not include potential changes associated with adding a Kingston stop, which could introduce further uncertainties related to geography, construction requirements and route selection.
The Parliamentary Budget Officer identified tunnelling, elevated structures, land acquisition and construction delays as important financial risks. According to its modelling, each additional kilometre of tunnelling could add approximately $169 million to project costs, while an additional kilometre of elevated railway could add roughly $153 million. Difficult terrain around Montréal and portions of the Canadian Shield further complicate construction planning. These figures raise a critical economic question: even if high-speed rail generates substantial productivity gains, how much will governments and passengers ultimately pay to deliver them? The new Aviseo report evaluates potential economic benefits but is not a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis. A complete assessment would also need to examine financing, operating expenses, future ticket revenue and the risks of cost overruns.
Farmers and Economists Are Calling for Closer Scrutiny of the Benefits
The project’s large potential benefits have not eliminated concerns among communities that could be affected by construction. In November, the Canadian Federation of Agriculture, Ontario Federation of Agriculture and Quebec’s Union des producteurs agricoles called for an immediate pause and an independent review of Alto. The organizations warned that a new railway corridor could divide farmland, disrupt drainage systems, reduce access to fields and interfere with agricultural operations. They also requested greater transparency concerning land acquisition, alternative routes and the project’s long-term financial implications.
A separate proposal supported by Quebec agricultural interests suggests that modernizing existing rail infrastructure could cost approximately $11 billion for an initial approach, although the resulting service would be slower and would not provide the same dedicated high-speed network. Alto disputes whether upgrading existing freight-dominated tracks could deliver comparable benefits. Other economic research offers additional context: the C.D. Howe Institute has estimated between $15 billion and $27 billion in discounted transportation and related benefits over 60 years under its scenarios. Those figures use a different framework and cannot be directly compared with Aviseo’s annual GDP estimate. For Canadian policymakers, the decision ultimately involves more than choosing between faster trains and existing infrastructure. It requires determining whether the anticipated gains are sufficiently reliable, widely shared and economically valuable to justify one of the largest transportation investments in the country’s history.
This Options Discord Chat is The Real Deal
While the internet is scoured with trading chat rooms, many of which even charge upwards of thousands of dollars to join, this smaller options trading discord chatroom is the real deal and actually providing valuable trade setups, education, and community without the noise and spam of the larger more expensive rooms. With a incredibly low-cost monthly fee, Options Trading Club (click here to see their reviews) requires an application to join ensuring that every member is dedicated and serious about taking their trading to the next level. If you are looking for a change in your trading strategies, then click here to apply for a membership.